This is a joke that us engineers used to make among ourselves back when I used to work at DuPont. It’s funny as a joke because, obviously, the more you flog somebody, the less likely that their morale will improve! Though, I must admit, that if you are flogging somebody and then decide to stop, that could make them a bit happier. Even though the flogging example seems obvious, I have noticed that many of us take the same sort of approach to trying to get other people to act in ways that we prefer (either because it is what we want or because we think it would be better for them). A common behavior modification technique is to “incentivize” someone by giving them a “negative” consequence if you don’t like their behavior. I see this all the time at the school where I work, with the consequences being detentions, low grades or even expulsion for really serious stuff. But it is also a common practice in parenting (I admit that I do my share of, “if you don’t start listening to me then you’ll never have dessert again in your life!”) Of course, I’ve been blessed with kids that call me on it every time I try it, but that’s the subject for its own post. You see it in relationships too, people yelling at each other or trying to lay guilt trips, etc.
Now don’t get me wrong – negative reinforcement does work with some of the people some of the time. For example, I used to fly around northern California in my Chevy Camaro, but when I finally got enough speeding tickets that I lost my auto insurance and was on the verge of losing my driver’s license, I did slow down. Similarly, there are lots of kids who change their behaviors when you threaten detentions and the threat of no dessert is especially effective in getting my 4 year old Bodhi to get a bath. But, in my experience, it only works when a person isn’t too far off of the desired behavior to begin with, and, especially in really difficult cases, this approach does much more harm than good and generally makes the problem worse.
As you know from my previous posts, I view a human being as energy. Now, if a kid is acting out in class, or a friend or family member is spazzing out on me, I always see it as a direct result of them not feeling good inside about something. That is, they are experiencing the energy of anger, resentment or some other lower vibration. Now if I lay some negative reinforcement on them, I am sending more negative energy to them. Unfortunately, in this situation, two negatives don’t make a positive and I am just deepening their bad feelings and just as in the flogging example, more negative feelings will not bring about positive reactions. Therefore, my approach is if I experience someone expressing negative, antisocial or downright nasty behavior, I do my best to give them feedback, but also to give them love. I don’t get mad, I don’t attack them, I don’t punish them. I try to work with them, to help them to feel heard, respected and valued. This doesn’t mean that I condone negative actions accept them. However, my approach does allow me to begin to build a bridge to the other person and moves towards healing rather than further wounding.
I feel that I have gotten great results with this approach. At the school where I teach, there have been certain situations where this approach helped me to build relationships with kids who have had trouble with almost everyone else that ultimately allow me to give them feedback that they can hear and have them be willing to consider suggestions that I make for change. However, be warned, if you try this at home you may be labeled “too soft”, ” a bleeding heart”, or someone who lets others “get away with murder”. However, if you truly want to be a healing force in this world and actually get positive results from people who can sometimes be a real pain in your arse at the same time – then I highly recommend it!
Try it and let me know how it goes. Remember, relationships are like growing a plant in a garden. You need to add a good deal of water, sunshine and love and it still takes time before you start to see the first signs of growth. Our negative feelings and inner hurts didn’t all happen overnight, so they probably won’t all be immediately and completely healed with one act of love – but at the very least, I promise that you will feel better taking this approach.
Never forget – it’s all about the love!
Tim



